Tis the season for festive flavors and no holiday fridge is complete without the rich, creamy presence of eggnog. While homemade recipes abound, sometimes convenience wins out, and that’s where grocery store varieties come in handy. But not all eggnogs are created equal, especially when it comes to finding the perfect one for spiking. For those looking to kick their holiday spirit up a notch with a boozy twist, we turned to the experts—bartenders—for their top picks on the best grocery store eggnogs.

First on the list is Horizon Organic Low Fat Eggnog. Bartenders appreciate its velvety smooth texture, which isn’t too thick, making it an ideal candidate for mixing with spirits. The gentle spices and subtle sweetness balance nicely when paired with darker liquors, such as bourbon or aged rum.

Southern Comfort Traditional Eggnog is another favorite among mixologists. This non-alcoholic version of the Southern classic is specifically designed to blend well with its namesake liquor, Southern Comfort. However, its well-rounded vanilla and spice flavors also make a perfect base for more traditional pairings like brandy or cognac.

Next up is Califia Farms Holiday Nog Almond Milk. Perfect for those seeking dairy-free options, bartenders point out that its lighter body is excellent for those who prefer their spiked eggnog less rich. Mix it with a spiced rum or an oat-based spirit to keep your holiday drink vegan-friendly.

For a lactose-free choice that doesn’t skimp on creaminess, lactose-intolerant revelers (and their bartenders) reach for Lactaid’s Eggnog. Its remarkably close to traditional eggnog and holds up well to spirits like whiskey or amaretto, allowing everyone to indulge in a delicious spiked treat without any discomfort.

Rounding out the top choices is Trader Joe’s Light Eggnog. While lighter in calories, bartenders note that it doesn’t sacrifice on taste and richness. It has the perfect consistency for adding a shot of espresso vodka or coffee liqueur for an unconventional but delightful eggnog experience.

In selecting the best grocery store eggnog to spike, bartenders advise looking for options that balance sweetness and spice while maintaining a consistency conducive to mixing. With these recommendations in hand, making merry this holiday season just got easier—and tastier!